Friday 23 November 2012

THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN ‘THE SYSTEM’ BY KONSTANTIN STANISLAVSKY & ‘BRECHTIAN ACTING TECHNIQUES’ BY BERTOLT BRECHT

STANISLAVSKY


            Konstantin Stanislavsky (1863-1938) is a father of modern acting techniques. He is a writer of the most influential acting lessons in modern times. He created the Moscow Art Theater (MAT) together with Vladimir Nemirovich-Danchenko in 1898. There are two personal traits that helped Stanislavsky in creating his method style of acting; first, his focus to study on other actors, and ability to assimilate their styles. Second, his ability to honestly review his own imperfections and adapt himself.

            In 1890, Stanislavsky saw a production by the Meiningen players (a German acting company). From this experience, he learned three important things in a theatre performance; which is the power of crowd scenes, importance of overall mood, and the value of a rigid acting discipline. Stanislavsky studied how people acted in everyday life, then found a way to bring this genuineness on stage .  He developed a series of exercises and techniques for the actor to follow. These are the basic techniques developed by him - relaxation, specificity, concentration and observation.  Relaxation involved removal of all tension; performer must attain a state of physical and vocal relaxation. Specificity refer to every concrete details, rather than generalities in acting. So every data in acting must be specified. Concentration and observation means an actor should be focus on one object, person or event. Then, this technique was develop by himself in his latest book. 

            Stanislavsky added  four new techniques which is the inner truth, 4W1H, super-objective, and ensemble playing. Inner truth is a way for characters to express, possibly non-verbally, their inner feelings. This technique used a word – “Magic If”. Using the “Magic If”, they can imagine how they would feel in certain situations. Then, they started to believe what they are doing through their character, not actual self. Through 4W1H, actor must ask themselves questions through this four – “What? Why? Who? How?”. They have to think answers of the questions related to their character. Then, actors have to transform their physical actions that link to all the answer. As example, an actor who played a postman role must think ‘How’ a postman cycling. Then, he must transform himself to the correct style how does a postman cycling; not a style like his common does as himself. Super-objective was shown through line of a role. It creates continuity of the character. Through this technique, a scene is divide into beats; the objectives of each beat should link to develop a through line for a character. In ensemble playing, all cast members should interact with each other. This is important to make the acting believable and seems natural.

            Stanislavskian technique always compared to other new technique by other theatre practitioners such as Meyehold, Boal, Artauld, and Brecht. Mostly Brecht, because there was major differences between this two and very contradict. Brechtian acting style was go against well made play shown in Stanislavsky works.

             Bertolt  Brecht (1898 – 1956) was a  famous Germany playwright, poet & theatre director. In the 1920’s, Brecht created a new form of theatre called Epic Theatre. Brecht known by his famous works entitle Mother Courage and Her Children. In 1920’s, Brecht started to develop his Epic Theatre. This came about as he started to reject idealism in favour for individualism. Epic theatre came about at a time when Melodrama, Realism and Naturalism were popular as theatre forms. Brecht’s theory, which he went on to call “Epic Theatre” were directed against the illusion created by traditional theatre in which the audience witnessed a slice of life. Instead he encouraged spectators to watch events on stage dispassionately and to reach their own conclusions.

             To prevent spectators from becoming emotionally involved Brecht used a variety of techniques, among them was the Verfremdungseffekt (Alienation or estrangement effect). This was achieved through such devices as; unfamiliar settings, interrupting the action with songs and announcing the contents of each scene through posters. Verfremdungseffekt was used to direct the audience’s attention to something new. This was done by getting the scene started, and then doing something unexpected. When the rhythm is interrupted, the audience stops getting lost in the emotion, story and characters. They are able to start to think and question. The idea with Verfremdungseffekt was to constantly remind the audience they were in a theatre, watching a play. These techniques break the illusion of drama. We do not get lost in the story or the characters. Instead we are constantly reminded that these are actors communicating ideas and situations to us.

             There are four strategy used by Brecht to create the Verfremdungseffekt. The strategy are marking the moment, cross-cutting, narration, and gestus. Brecht used a number of techniques to ‘Mark the Moment’, for example; an unfamiliar pause at an important/dramatic moment of the play, playing  a dramatic moment in slow motion, using narration, a song or music.  Songs and music were used to comment on the action, not to move the narrative on and also to interrupt the action. Cross-cutting means creating a scene or scenes and then reordering the action by ‘cutting’ forwards and backwards to different moments. It also called montage. Montage connected unrelated scenes to give new meanings by broke down action into minute details. Narration providing a spoken commentary that accompanies stage action, or a story being related by a character. Brecht often encouraged his actors to comment in character (while on stage), on how to play the next part of the scene or sometimes confront with the narrator. The last strategy said above is gestus. Gestus means attitude, but it actually refer to how an actor creating meaning and communicating a message to the audience. Gestus also has been interpreted in many different ways. It can be related to individual characters, the whole scene, or the music. Gestus can be shown in individual characters by the combination of gesture and facial expression; and body language is deliberately used to emphasise meaning and communicate a message to the audience. This is influenced by the control and attention to detail of Charlie Chaplin. Meanwhile, in the whole scene; its refer to the meaning conveyed by the ‘whole picture’ of a scene. Then, music illustrates an incident on the stage – comments on the action and reinforces and exemplifies a text’s meaning.

             Brecht believed that the actor’s job was merely to show what happened. He did not want actors to identify with the character or to play the role realistically, which was the opposite of Stanislavsky’s purpose.


BRECHT

No comments:

Post a Comment